I first noticed the Herschel suitcase when it was being wheeled ahead of me onto a jetbridge. The suitcase looked sleek and sturdy, and I was intrigued. After researching the luggage thoroughly, I decided to splurge on the carry-on to test out myself. I chose the Herschel Supply Co. Heritage Hardshell Large Carry-on 43L because it was the biggest size that still met the carry-on requirements for most airlines. I was tempted by the pretty Moonbeam color but feared it would get scuffed and dirty quickly, so I ended up with basic black.
I’ve put this carry-on to the test in real-world travel scenarios to find out if it lived up to my expectations. This review will cover the suitcase’s performance in key areas such as durability, maneuverability, and storage capacity, helping you decide if the Herschel Supply hardshell carry-on 43L is the right choice for your travel needs.
Herschel Suitcase Luggage Size
Herschel Supply Co. has two different sizes of carry-on suitcases. Here are the differences between the two.
Herschel Suitcase | Overall Dimensions | Weight | Price |
Carry-on 35L | 19.69″(H) x 13.99″(W) x 9.06″(D) | 6.15 lbs / 2.8 kg | $225 |
Large Carry-on 43L | 21.25″(H) x 14.25″(W) x 9.50″(D), 43.0”L | 6.5 lbs / 3 kg | $250 |
Herschel Supply Co. Heritage Hardshell Large Carry-on 43L Luggage Review
Pros
- Large size can hold enough for longer trips
- Fairly lightweight at 6.5 lbs
- Made from recycled road barricade material on the outside and recycled water bottles on the inside
- Stylish design
- Unique colors available
- Multi-stage locking suitcase handle lets you set it at the perfect height for you
- Hinomoto wheels spin 360 degrees are silent and smooth rolling
- Easy to wheel and maneuver even when full
- Internal zippered mesh storage sleeve is perfect for storing small items
- Elastic straps keep everything secure
- TSA-approved lock
- Reinforced corners add to durability
Cons
- Herschel logo is very prominent and detracts from the look of the bag
- No compression board
- Does not fit carry-on requirements for some airlines
- Only one zippered pocket
- Overpriced unless you buy on sale
Overall Verdict
The Herschel Supply Hardshell Carry-on Suitcase 43L impresses with its blend of style, functionality, and eco-conscious design. Its spacious interior and lightweight build make it a solid choice for longer trips, while the recycled materials used in construction earn it points for sustainability. The suitcase shines in maneuverability, thanks to its multi-stage handle and smooth Hinomoto wheels, ensuring a hassle-free airport experience.
I accidentally dropped this suitcase down a full flight of stairs not long after buying it, and it emerged without a dent or scratch, which speaks to its durability.
However, it’s not without its drawbacks. The prominent Herschel logo may not appeal to all travelers, and the lack of a compression board or multiple pockets could be a deal-breaker for organization enthusiasts.
Despite these cons, the suitcase’s durability, design, and size make it a worthy contender in the luggage market. For travelers who don’t mind using packing cubes to stay organized, the Herschel Supply hardshell 43L offers a compelling package—just be sure to check your airline’s size restrictions before committing to this fashionable travel companion.
Price and Where to Buy
The Herschel suitcase costs $250 at full price, but I bought mine on sale on Amazon. I’ve also found good deals on the bag on Zappos.
Herschel Supply Suitcase Dupes
The Herschel Supply Carry-on is a bit overpriced for what you get. Here are some affordable dupes I recommend:
- Samsonite Omni 2 Hardside Expandable Luggage with Spinners
- Hardshell Coolife Luggage
- Samsonite Freeform Hardsided Expandable Spinner
- Traveler’s Choice Pagosa Indestructible Hardsided Spinner
- Vera Bradley 22” Spinner
- Mixi 21” Hardshell Carry-on Suitcase
Read our other luggage reviews, including:
- Ricardo Carry-On With Front Opening Review
- Lululemon Everywhere Belt Bag Review
- Samsonite Freeform 21” Carry-On Hardside review
- Samsonite Outline Pro Carry-On Review
- The Ultimate Rimowa Carry-On Suitcase Review
- Samsonite C-Lite Carry-On Spinner Review
- Roam Luggage Carry-On Suitcase Review
- Dagne Dover Dakota Neoprene Backpack Review
- Carl Friedrik Palissy Weekend Bag Review